Your report is full of activity and short on results
The monthly marketing report usually looks busy. There are posts published, impressions, clicks, open rates, followers and a long table of campaigns. Then the owner asks a simple question: what did we get for the money? The room goes quiet, because the report was built to show what the team did, not what the business gained.
This is a common problem, and it is fixable. Activity measures are easy to collect. Each platform produces its own figures automatically, and each channel reports its own version of success. That makes it tempting to report what is easy to count rather than what matters commercially. The result is a pile of numbers that nobody uses to make a decision.
The problem usually grows slowly. Each new channel adds a section to the report, and each new campaign adds a row. The report gets longer without getting clearer. By the time someone asks for a commercial view, the team has a great deal of data and very little agreement about what it means.
Commercial marketing is a different discipline. It asks one question of every activity: what will this change in sales, margin or qualified pipeline, and how will we know? Activity still matters, because it is how the work gets done. But activity is the means, not the result.
The rest of this guide sets out a practical way to make that shift without rebuilding the whole function. Start with one goal. Choose a short list of measures and put them on one page. Review them every month. Then use the review to decide what to keep, what to change and what to stop.
What commercial marketing means in practice
Commercial marketing is not a rejection of brand work, content or creative. It is a rule about how the work is judged. Each activity needs a stated link to one of three commercial outcomes: sales, margin or qualified pipeline. If an activity cannot be linked to any of them, ask whether it is needed at all.
Three questions help test an activity before it goes into the plan:
- Which commercial outcome does this move: sales, margin or qualified pipeline?
- What will we measure, and what result would count as success?
- What will we stop or change if the result does not come?
The third question is the one most plans skip. Without it, every activity becomes permanent, because nobody agreed in advance what failure would look like. Setting the test before the work starts makes the later review honest.
Here is how the test works in practice. Suppose a business plans a series of articles aimed at a new sector. The commercial outcome is qualified pipeline from that sector. The measure is the number of qualified enquiries that come from the sector after the series is published. The stop rule is agreed in advance: if the series has produced no qualified enquiries after the agreed period, the next series is changed or dropped, not simply repeated.
Brand activity can take longer to show a commercial effect. That does not exempt it from the rule. Agree a leading measure in advance, such as the share of new enquiries that come through referrals from existing clients, and review it on a fixed date. The measurement side of this is covered on the marketing science page.
Set one commercial goal for the period
Start with a single goal. It should name a commercial outcome, a size and a period. For example: increase qualified enquiries from two named sectors over the next twelve months, or improve gross margin on one product range over the next two quarters. Write it as one sentence that anyone in the team could repeat from memory.
Here is an example of a goal that is too loose: grow the business and do more marketing. It names no outcome, no size and no period, so any activity can claim to support it. Tighten it by naming the outcome, the sector, the size of the change and the date. The sentence then tells the team what to aim for and what to leave alone.
One goal forces trade-offs. When there are three priorities, every channel can claim to help, and the budget gets spread thinly across all of them. A single goal makes it clear which activities serve it and which compete with it. That is the real reason to choose one.
Agree the goal with the people who will own the results. Sales, finance and marketing should all accept that it is the right goal and that it can be measured. If finance cannot see the margin figure, or sales does not recognise the pipeline definition, the goal will not survive its first review.
Be realistic about what the goal can achieve in the period. A target that is clearly out of reach encourages people to report activity instead of results. Pick a figure that is ambitious but based on the business's own history. Revisit it once you have a clean baseline, and adjust it only with a written reason.
Choose a small set of measures
Pick three to five measures that connect the activity to the goal. Put the commercial measures at the top and the activity measures underneath. Activity measures help you diagnose problems, but they should not be the headline. A practical starting set might include:
- Qualified enquiries per month, using a written definition of qualified
- Pipeline value created from marketing sources
- Win rate on opportunities from marketing sources
- Average contract or order value
- Gross margin on business that marketing helped to win
- Cost of marketing per qualified enquiry
Define each measure in writing before you start. A measure without a definition gets counted differently by different people, and then the trend means nothing. Say what counts, where the data comes from, who updates it and how often. Limit the list to measures you can collect at least once a month. A measure that takes a week to pull from three systems will be skipped the first time the month gets busy.
Attribution will never be perfect. Some enquiries come from word of mouth, and some buyers see several things before they get in touch. Accept that the figures are an honest estimate, use the same method every month and be clear about what the method cannot show. Search is a good example of where this gets hard. For how to plan search work, see why SEO and GEO need two plans.
Illustration only. Suppose a business spends £6,000 a month on marketing and receives 40 qualified enquiries. That is £150 for each qualified enquiry. Suppose one in five of those becomes a win, which gives eight wins, with an average contract of £9,000. That is £72,000 of contract value from marketing-sourced business. These figures are not a benchmark. Your own costs, conversion rates and contract values will differ. The point is the method, not the numbers.
Build a one-page scorecard and review it monthly
A scorecard should fit on one page. It shows the goal at the top and one row for each measure. Each row has a target, the actual result for the month, the trend over the last three months, the owner and the next action. If a row needs a paragraph of explanation, the measure is probably too complicated.
Suppose one row reads: qualified enquiries from marketing, target 40 a month, actual 34, down for two months, owner the marketing lead, next action to test a revised offer with the two sectors that respond best. Anyone in the meeting can follow that row, and it is clear enough to decide what happens next.
Keep the layout plain. A table in a spreadsheet, a single slide or a printed sheet is enough. What matters is that everyone looks at the same numbers, from the same source, at the same time each month. A dashboard with fifty charts is harder to act on than one page with five measures.
Hold the review on the same day each month, using a fixed agenda. Cover progress against the goal, what changed in the month and why, which activities are working, which are not, and what will be decided before the next review. Keep the meeting short. Every action needs an owner and a date.
The review is where decisions get made. Sales should bring the feedback that numbers cannot show: which enquiries were poor fits, which objections came up on calls and which messages landed. Marketing should explain what it changed and what it expected to happen. Both should then agree the next step, and write it down.
Decide what to stop and what to protect
A review that only adds activity is a budget problem waiting to happen. Each month, look at the activities on the scorecard and ask whether they still earn their place. Stopping is a decision, and it needs criteria just as starting does.
Stop an activity when it has had a fair test and has not moved its measure. Stop it when it duplicates another activity that does the same job better, or when its cost cannot be justified against the commercial outcome. Also stop anything nobody can explain. If the owner cannot say what an activity is for, the cost is not justified.
Check the source before you cut anything. A small, quiet activity can carry a large share of qualified enquiries, while a busy, visible one can produce very little. Before a stop decision, look at where the qualified pipeline actually came from, and only then decide.
Protect the activities that feed the goal but show results slowly. Brand work, content and relationship building often fall into this group. Protect them with a leading measure and a review date, rather than by exempting them from the scorecard. That keeps the protection honest and visible.
Be open about what you stop. Moving budget from one channel to another without a recorded decision is not a change of strategy. Record the reason, the expected effect and the date you will check it. That record protects the next decision from the same argument.
What to do next: this week, write the one-sentence goal and agree it with sales and finance. Then list every current activity and the commercial outcome each one is meant to move. Build the one-page scorecard with no more than five measures, and hold the first review next month. Make the first stop decisions at that review, using the first set of numbers. Anything with no stated purpose can be stopped straight away.
See which of your marketing activity earns its place
If your marketing reports are full of activity but short on commercial results, book a discovery call. We will look at your goal, your measures and your current activity with you, and agree which part of the plan to test first.
Book a discovery callQuestions and answers
What is commercial marketing?
Commercial marketing judges every activity by its effect on sales, margin or qualified pipeline. It does not mean dropping brand, content or creative work. It means each piece of work has a stated commercial outcome, a measure and a review date, so the business can see what it earned and decide what to keep, change or stop.
How many measures should a marketing scorecard have?
Three to five is a practical range for most businesses. Put the commercial measures first, such as qualified enquiries, pipeline value and win rate, and keep activity measures underneath for diagnosis. Each measure needs a written definition, a data source, an owner and a monthly target, so that the scorecard can be read quickly and trusted.
Should brand marketing be judged on sales?
Brand work often takes longer to show a sales effect, so judge it on agreed leading measures and a fixed review date rather than on one month of sales. Choose the measures in advance, such as enquiries from new sectors or the share of referrals from existing clients, and be clear about what each measure can and cannot show.
What should we stop doing first?
Start with activity that has no stated commercial outcome, that nobody can explain, or that duplicates another activity. Then look at work that has had a fair test and has not moved its measure. Record the reason for each stop, the expected effect and the date you will check it, so the decision is clear and can be revisited.