Why project revenue resets every month
A project agency is always one contract away from a quiet month. The pipeline has to be refilled for every new brief, the team is redeployed when a project ends, and cash arrives in lumps that are hard to forecast. Owners often describe this as a sales problem, but it is usually a model problem. The agency is selling time-limited work to clients who need ongoing results.
The fix is not to stop doing projects. Projects are a useful way to start a relationship and to deliver specific work. The fix is to identify the part of the client's need that does not end when the project does, and to sell that part as a retained service. The project then becomes the first step into a longer engagement, rather than the whole of it.
A retainer also changes how the agency runs. Revenue becomes predictable enough to plan people and investment. Account managers can focus on outcomes rather than on the next proposal. And the agency can say no to the work that does not fit, because the recurring base covers the overheads.
Decide what belongs in a retainer
Not every piece of work should be retained. A retainer works best when the work is repeatable, when its output can be measured, and when the client needs decisions to be made on a regular cycle. If you sell a retainer for work that is really a one-off build, the client will feel they are paying for nothing in the months when nothing new is delivered.
Three tests help separate retainable work from project work:
- Is the work repeatable? Content production, search optimisation, paid media management, reporting and conversion testing all recur. A website rebuild does not, although maintenance and iteration of the site can.
- Can the output be measured? The client should be able to see what the retainer delivered each month, in terms they recognise, such as enquiries, sales, search visibility or store visits.
- Does the client need ongoing decisions? Markets change, channels move and budgets are reallocated. Work that needs a monthly decision is a good candidate for a retainer. Work that is finished once is not.
The output of this exercise is a list of services that can be bundled. Keep the list short. A retainer with five or six clearly defined components is easier to sell and to deliver than one that tries to cover everything the agency has ever done.
Build a productised offer with clear tiers
Once you know what belongs in the retainer, package it. A productised offer has a name, a defined scope, a set of deliverables, a reporting rhythm and a price. It can be explained in a single conversation, and two clients buying the same tier will receive the same service.
Most agencies work well with three tiers. The first tier covers the essentials. The second adds the work that most clients need to grow. The third adds senior input, testing and faster turnaround. The middle tier should be the one you most want to sell, because it gives the client a clear path to results without the cost of the top tier.
For each tier, write down:
- The services included, and the ones that are explicitly excluded.
- The monthly deliverables, such as a number of content pieces, campaign changes or review meetings.
- The reporting: what the client will see, how often, and in what format.
- The review points, at which the scope and the budget can be changed with notice.
Write the scope tightly. The most common reason retainers become unprofitable is scope creep, where extra requests arrive without any change to the price. A clear list of what is included, and a simple process for adding work, protects both the margin and the relationship.
Price on value and scope, not on hours
Hourly pricing encourages hours. If the client pays for time, the agency has an incentive to take longer, and the client has an incentive to question every hour. A retainer priced on scope and value removes that tension. The client pays for a defined service and a defined result, and the agency is rewarded for doing the work efficiently.
There are several ways to set the price. Many agencies start from the cost of delivery, add a margin they can sustain, and then test the number against the value the client expects. Others start from the commercial goal and work back, showing the client what a given level of investment is likely to be worth. Both approaches are better than pricing by hour, provided the assumptions are explicit.
Whatever method you use, keep the price in proportion to the work, and be willing to explain it. A client who understands why a tier costs what it does is far less likely to haggle over the detail, and far more likely to stay when the first review arrives.
Convert existing project clients first
The cheapest retainer to win is the one with a client who already trusts you. Most project clients will need the work to continue in some form, but they will not always know that unless you show them. The conversation should happen before the project ends, not after the final invoice.
A good handover includes a short plan for the next three months, showing what the results so far suggest, what would make them stronger, and what it would take to keep the momentum. The plan is not a sales document. It is a clear account of what the client would lose if the work stopped, and it makes the retainer the natural next step.
Keep the conversation specific. Name the channels that have worked, the metrics that have moved and the next decisions that need to be made. A client who can see the next decision is much more likely to agree to a retainer than one who has been offered a generic service.
Build the delivery system before you sell it
A retainer is a promise to deliver every month, and that is harder than winning the contract. Before you sell a tier, make sure the agency can deliver it consistently with the people, tools and reporting it needs.
In practice this means four things. Write a playbook for each service, so that the work is done the same way every time. Build reporting templates that can be filled in quickly and sent on schedule. Assign an account lead who owns the relationship and the outcome. And plan the capacity: how many accounts each team member can manage at a sustainable pace, and when the next hire is needed.
Many agencies sell retainers before they have these systems, then struggle to deliver. Clients notice quickly. Build the system with the first few retained clients, then codify it, and only then increase the number of tiers or the volume you sell.
Red-Fern shows the sequence in practice. The team first built revenue operations, then hired and trained the team, after the performance offer had been defined. The retained offer was sold on the basis of the work and the data behind it, rather than on the promise of a new team.
Measure what the retainer is doing
A retainer should be managed like a portfolio, not like a set of individual projects. The useful measures are the ones that show whether the recurring revenue is growing, whether it is staying, and whether it is profitable.
- Monthly recurring revenue: the total value of retained contracts each month, and how it changes as clients join, expand or leave.
- Retention: the share of retained revenue that renews. A falling retention rate is an early warning that the offer, the delivery or the reporting needs attention.
- Expansion: the revenue added by existing clients moving up a tier or adding a service. Expansion is usually cheaper to win than new business.
- Margin by account: the profit each retained client makes after delivery costs. Scope creep shows up here first.
Review these measures monthly, alongside the commercial results the retainer is meant to deliver. The aim is to see early when a client is drifting, and to fix the scope or the delivery before the renewal conversation.
What it looked like for two agencies
The principle is easier to see in practice. Red-Fern was a project-only brand, web and software agency. Its growth depended on winning the next project, and its revenue reset each time one ended. The change was to build a performance offer of seven retained service lines, including SEO, GEO, PPC, paid social, LinkedIn, Amazon and CRO, and to turn project clients into recurring accounts. The agency restructured for margin to fit the new revenue mix, and built £1.2m of recurring revenue in 15 months.
Media Performance was a 20-year-old offline TV and radio agency with no performance capability. Its anchor client had been lost, and its revenue was highly concentrated. The agency built a performance offer and a framework for measuring results across brand and performance, then repositioned itself around outcomes rather than media space. The work generated £1.5m of retained performance revenue.
In both cases the retainer was not a discount on the old way of working. It was a different service, designed around the client's ongoing needs, delivered with a system, and measured against the outcomes that mattered to the client.
Put this into practice
If you are considering a retained offer, or you want to move existing project clients onto one, book a discovery call. We will look at your current revenue, your delivery capacity and the services that could be retained, and agree what to test first.
Talk about your agencyQuestions and answers
Can a small agency move to retainers?
Yes. Start with one productised service and one tier, sell it to existing clients, and build the delivery system around it. Add tiers and services once the first retained accounts are running well.
What about clients who only want projects?
Keep a project option for work that is genuinely one-off, but price it so that it does not undercut the retainer. Make the retainer the default recommendation, and explain why.
How do we handle a client who wants to leave a retainer?
Agree the notice period, the review points and the scope in writing from the start. A clear exit process reduces disputes and often keeps the relationship on good terms for a future return.
How do we stop scope creep?
Define what each tier includes and excludes, add a simple change process for extra requests, and review scope at each review point. Track margin by account so that drift is visible early.