Why crowded markets are harder

When many brands sell similar products, AI tools lean on the sources that describe them most clearly and most often. The leading brands usually have more reviews, more press and more pages, so they start with an advantage. A new or smaller brand cannot out-publish them across the whole category.

The data shows how concentrated visibility is. Ahrefs' study of 75,000 brands found that brands in the top quarter for web mentions averaged 169 mentions in Google's AI Overviews, while the next quarter averaged just 14, and 26% of brands were not mentioned at all (Ahrefs, 2025). Visibility in AI answers is not spread evenly; it gathers around the brands that are already widely discussed.

Big general sources also take a large share of broad questions. Pew Research Center found that Wikipedia, YouTube and Reddit were the most cited sources in both Google's AI summaries and its standard results, together making up 15% of the sources cited in AI summaries (Pew Research Center, 2025).

A smaller brand cannot win that contest head on. It can, however, out-specify the leaders on the questions where it is strongest.

Why it is worth the effort

Shoppers are using AI tools to choose. Adobe's survey of more than 5,000 US consumers, published in March 2025, found that 39% had used generative AI for online shopping, with research (55%) and product recommendations (47%) the most common uses. Adobe also recorded a 1,300% year-on-year rise in traffic from generative AI sources to US retail sites over the 2024 holiday period (Adobe, 2025). That growth came from a small base, and those visitors were 9% less likely to convert than other traffic at the time, but they bounced 23% less often and viewed more pages per visit.

Local discovery is moving too. BrightLocal's 2026 survey of 1,002 US adults found that 45% had used an AI tool to find local business recommendations in the past year, up from 6%, with 31% using ChatGPT for this (BrightLocal, 2026). Both studies are US-only. UK data is thinner, but Ofcom reports that ChatGPT received 1.8 billion UK visits in the first eight months of 2025, around five times the figure for the same period a year earlier (Ofcom, 2025).

When an AI answer appears, fewer people click through to compare options for themselves. Pew found that clicks on traditional results fell from 15% to 8% of visits when a Google AI summary was shown (Pew Research Center, 2025). Being named in the answer is increasingly what counts.

Choose the questions you can win

Narrow questions are where challengers have the best chance. Research presented at the KDD conference in 2024 found that content changes such as citing sources and adding statistics lifted visibility far more for pages ranked fifth in search results than for top-ranked pages. For fifth-placed pages, citing sources raised visibility in AI answers by about 115%, while top-ranked pages lost ground (Aggarwal et al., 2024). The study used a test environment rather than live commercial AI tools, but it suggests clear, evidenced content helps challengers more than leaders.

Look for questions that are narrower than the category, where your offer has a clear edge:

  • Use-case questions, such as "which running shoe suits wide feet" or "which snack suits a school lunch box".
  • Comparison questions, where you can explain honestly when you are the better choice.
  • Location or channel questions, such as "where to buy" or "which retailers stock".
  • Problem questions, where your product solves something rivals ignore.

Build proof that AI tools can cite

Independent reviews, comparison tests, customer studies and clear product specifications all give AI tools something to quote. Put them on pages that are easy to find, not in a PDF that only your sales team holds.

Digital PR can earn mentions in the publications that rivals already appear in. A single credible feature often does more for AI visibility than a dozen posts on your own site.

Being cited pays off in clicks as well as mentions. Seer Interactive's 2025 analysis of 42 client organisations found that brands cited in Google's AI Overviews had a 35% higher organic click-through rate than brands that were not cited, based on Q3 2025 averages, though Seer notes it cannot show the citation caused the difference (Seer Interactive, 2025).

For retail brands, keep product data clean. Google advises keeping Merchant Center and Business Profile information up to date and making sure structured data matches the visible page (Google Search Central, 2026). Accurate prices, availability and specifications make it easier for AI shopping features to describe your products correctly.

Work the sources rivals ignore

Many category leaders focus on national media and overlook niche directories, specialist forums, retailer category pages and partner sites. These are often the sources AI tools use to build a shortlist for a narrow question. Make sure your brand is accurate and complete on each one.

Accuracy is worth checking source by source. When the European Broadcasting Union and the BBC had journalists assess more than 3,000 AI answers about news in 2025, 31% had missing or misleading sourcing and 20% had major accuracy issues, such as outdated information (EBU and BBC, 2025). Out-of-date listings and stale product details are an easy way for an assistant to describe you wrongly. Start with these:

  • Specialist review sites and comparison publishers in your category.
  • Retailer and marketplace product pages, including their reviews.
  • Niche forums and community threads where buyers ask for advice.
  • YouTube reviews and product demonstrations.
  • Trade and local directories.

Measure progress against named rivals

Pick three named competitors and test the same questions each month. Record who is named, how they are described and which source is cited. Our guide to running an AI visibility audit sets out the method, and it works the same way in consumer categories as in B2B.

Track share of voice: your mentions as a share of all brand mentions for each question group. For example, if a hypothetical sports nutrition brand is named in 6 of 40 runs on "best protein bar for runners" while its three rivals are named 30 times between them, its share is 6 of 36 mentions, about 17%. Watch that figure move question group by question group, rather than as one blended number.

Report it alongside commercial results. Our retail and ecommerce and consumer brands work connects visibility to sales, not only to mentions.

Common mistakes, and what good looks like

Good looks like a brand that is consistently named for a defined set of narrow questions, described accurately, and cited from a mix of its own pages and trusted third-party sources. From there, it widens the set one question group at a time. With more than 800 million people using ChatGPT every week, according to OpenAI's chief executive (TechCrunch, 2025), even a narrow set of questions can reach a meaningful audience.

If you use an agency or a tracking tool, ask how it chooses the questions, how many times it runs each one, which rivals it benchmarks against and how it checks whether answers describe you accurately. Ask, too, how it will link changes in visibility to traffic, sales or store visits. A supplier that reports only a single visibility score, with no view of the questions, sources and descriptions behind it, gives you little to act on.

The mistakes in crowded markets are usually about scale and focus:

  • Chasing broad category questions the market leaders already own.
  • Publishing lots of thin content instead of a few well-evidenced pages.
  • Ignoring retailer, review and forum sources.
  • Measuring a single run, rather than a pattern across runs and months.
  • Treating AI visibility as separate from PR and SEO, when the same sources drive all three.

Put this into practice

Book a discovery call and we will review your channels and results first, then agree what to test.

Get your free AI position report

Questions and answers

Can a smaller brand beat larger ones in AI answers?

Yes, on specific questions. Larger brands tend to dominate broad questions, while smaller brands can become the recommended answer for a narrow use case, region or customer type.

Which channel should lead?

Start with the sources that already shape the category, which is usually a mix of digital PR and well-structured content on your own site. Then track the results in SEO and GEO reporting.

How many rivals should we track?

Three to five is enough for most brands: the market leader, one or two direct competitors of a similar size, and any challenger that keeps appearing in AI answers. Tracking more makes the data harder to act on.

Do reviews affect AI visibility?

They appear to. AI tools often draw on review sites, retailer pages and forums when answering shopping questions, so a steady flow of genuine, detailed reviews gives them more to work with. Never buy or fake reviews: it breaks platform rules and UK consumer protection law.

Should we create content for every product?

Not at first. Start with the products and questions where you have a real edge, and make those pages as specific and well-evidenced as possible. Widen coverage once those pages are being cited.

How long does it take to break into AI answers in a crowded category?

Expect several months. Fixes to your own product and category pages can be picked up once they are recrawled, but the reviews, features and listings that persuade AI tools to name a challenger build gradually. Test the same questions monthly and judge progress over at least a quarter.

References

  1. Ahrefs, "An Analysis of AI Overview Brand Visibility Factors (75K Brands Studied)", 2025
  2. Pew Research Center, "Google users are less likely to click on links when an AI summary appears in the results", 2025
  3. Adobe, "Adobe Analytics: Traffic to U.S. retail websites from Generative AI sources jumps 1,200 percent", 2025
  4. BrightLocal, "Local Consumer Review Survey 2026: AI and trust", 2026
  5. Ofcom, "From apps to AI search: how the UK goes online in 2025", 2025
  6. Aggarwal et al., "GEO: Generative Engine Optimization" (KDD 2024), 2024
  7. Seer Interactive, "AIO Impact on Google CTR: September 2025 Update", 2025
  8. Google Search Central, "AI features and your website", 2026
  9. EBU and BBC, "Largest study of its kind shows AI assistants misrepresent news content 45% of the time" (announcement via VRT), 2025
  10. TechCrunch, "Sam Altman says ChatGPT has hit 800M weekly active users", 2025

This article is adapted from ContxtAI's article on LLM visibility breakthroughs in competitive markets, rewritten for Insight Labs readers.

← Back to all articles