Pitches cost more time than most agencies track
You open an email with a pitch invitation. The brief is short, the deadline is ten days away, and the buyer has not said what they want to achieve. Your instinct says to reply yes, because new business keeps the pipeline full. The trouble is that the same instinct has sent many agencies into pitches that never had a real chance.
The cost is easy to miss because it is spread across the team. A partner reads the brief and joins the first call. A strategist builds the approach. A creative lead produces ideas that may never be shown. An account director writes the proposal and rehearses the presentation. Each hour looks reasonable on its own. Added together, the time can be large, and it comes out of the same people who serve existing clients.
Time spent on the wrong pitch is also time not spent on a better opportunity. Every weak pitch pushes back other work that could have produced a stronger result, such as a follow-up with a warm lead, a review with a current client or a conversation with a referral. The aim is not to pitch less for its own sake. It is to put your best people where the odds are better.
The fix is a repeatable test. A pitch score is a short, written model that rates each opportunity against the same criteria before you commit serious time. It does not replace judgement. It makes the judgement consistent, visible and easier to review later.
Why a written score beats gut feel
Gut feel works well for experienced people, until it does not. The pitches that feel most exciting are often the ones the team most wants to win, which is not the same as the ones it is best placed to win. A written score separates the two. It asks the same questions each time and records the answers, so the decision does not depend on who was most enthusiastic in the meeting that week.
A written model also helps the team agree. When a partner says a pitch is worth chasing, the score shows which criteria they are relying on. If the budget criterion is low, the conversation moves to the budget, not to a general argument about whether the pitch is good. That is a more productive debate, and it is easier to have when nobody is defending a decision they have already half made.
Over time, the records show patterns. You may find that pitches with a stated goal and a named decision-maker close more often than requests that arrive through procurement with no brief. Or you may find the opposite in your sector. Either way, the pattern comes from your own results, not from a general rule that someone else has written.
A score is not a forecast. It is a way to decide where to spend limited time. A well-scored pitch can still be lost, and a weak one can occasionally be won. The value comes from making many decisions consistently across a year, not from being right about any single pitch. For what happens once you have decided to pitch, read how to win more agency pitches.
Seven criteria to score every pitch
Keep the list short enough to use in about ten minutes. Seven criteria cover the points that most often decide whether a pitch is worth pursuing. Each one needs a clear definition, so that two people scoring the same pitch reach similar answers.
The list below sets out each criterion and the question to ask. Put the questions into your scoring sheet, so that everyone uses them in the same way.
- Commercial goal: Has the buyer stated a goal in commercial terms, such as more qualified enquiries, higher margin or a launch tied to revenue?
- Budget: Is there a defined budget or a realistic range, and has the buyer confirmed that it is approved?
- Decision-makers: Do you know who will decide, who will influence and who will sign, and have you met at least one of them?
- Timing: Does the decision date leave enough time to prepare a strong response, and does the work start soon after the decision?
- Fit: Does the work sit within the sectors and services you know well, so you can show real understanding of the buyer's market?
- Competition: How many agencies are likely to be invited, and do you have a credible edge over them?
- Evidence: Can you show relevant work or references that match this buyer's situation, within the limits of client confidentiality?
Two of these criteria are often underrated. Decision-makers tell you whether the pitch is real. A buyer who will not name anyone else involved may be asking for free ideas. Evidence matters because buyers judge risk. If you cannot show work that looks like theirs, they will ask why they should take the chance on you.
Be honest when you score. A common mistake is to give a criterion a high mark because the agency would like to win in that sector, rather than because the evidence supports it. Score what you know. Mark unknowns as zero, and treat each one as a reason to ask questions before you commit.
Weighting the criteria and scoring each pitch
Not every criterion matters equally. A clear commercial goal and a confirmed budget usually matter more than competition, which you cannot control. Weight the criteria so that they add up to 100. The weights are a judgement about what matters to your agency, so agree them with the partners and test them against past wins and losses.
Suppose you set these weights as an illustration: commercial goal 20, budget 20, decision-makers 15, timing 10, fit 15, competition 10 and evidence 10. Score each criterion from 0 to 5, where 5 is strong and 0 means unknown or absent. To get the points for a criterion, divide its score by 5 and multiply by its weight. A pitch scoring 4 on the commercial goal earns 16 out of 20.
Keep the scale simple. A five-point scale is easy to remember and easy to defend in a team meeting. Scales with many more points suggest a precision that the information rarely supports, and they slow people down.
Write one line of evidence beside each score. For example, "budget 3: range given in the brief, not yet approved" tells a reader exactly why the mark is what it is. The note is what makes the score useful later, because it shows what would have changed the mark.
- Score each criterion from 0 to 5, using the same definitions every time.
- Divide each score by 5, then multiply by the criterion's weight to get its points.
- Add the points for a total out of 100.
- Record one line of evidence for each criterion.
Three outcomes and a worked example
The total leads to one of three outcomes. Pursue means the pitch is worth full effort. Qualify further means the pitch has potential, but one or more gaps need closing before you commit, such as a confirmed budget or a meeting with the decision-maker. Decline means the odds or the fit are too weak to justify the time, and the reason should be recorded.
Set the thresholds once, then review them. As an illustration only, you might use 70 or more for pursue, 50 to 69 for qualify further, and below 50 for decline. These are not benchmarks. The right numbers depend on your margins, your capacity and your own win history. Add one rule of your own: a pitch that scores 0 on the commercial goal should not be pursued, however high its total, because a pitch with no stated goal is hard to win.
Here is a worked example with invented scores. Suppose a manufacturer asks your agency to pitch for a B2B marketing programme. The brief states a goal of growing qualified enquiries from two export markets. Each criterion is scored as follows:
- Commercial goal: 4 out of 5, earning 16 of 20 points
- Budget: 3 out of 5, earning 12 of 20 points
- Decision-makers: 3 out of 5, earning 9 of 15 points
- Timing: 4 out of 5, earning 8 of 10 points
- Fit: 4 out of 5, earning 12 of 15 points
- Competition: 3 out of 5, earning 6 of 10 points
- Evidence: 4 out of 5, earning 8 of 10 points
The total is 71 out of 100, so the outcome is pursue. Three criteria sit at 3 out of 5: budget, decision-makers and competition. Budget and decision-makers are the gaps to close first. Before the agency spends serious time, the account lead should confirm the budget range and arrange a call with the marketing director. If either cannot be confirmed, the outcome moves to qualify further, and the proposal waits.
Record scores and check the model each quarter
Record every scored pitch in one shared sheet. Include the date, the buyer, the score for each criterion, the total, the outcome and a short reason. Add the result later: won, lost, withdrawn or no decision, and roughly how many hours the pitch took. Keep the sheet simple enough that the team will fill it in on the day of the decision, not weeks later.
Once a quarter, review the record. Compare the scores with the outcomes. Ask whether pursue decisions won at a reasonable rate, whether declined opportunities went to competitors you would have beaten, and whether particular criteria seemed to predict results better than others. Look at hours as well. A model that sends most of the time to the lowest-margin work needs changing.
Change the model carefully. Adjust one weight or threshold at a time, and keep the previous version so you can compare. A small sample makes almost any pattern look stronger than it is, so give the model several quarters of data before you make large changes.
What to do next: this week, write down your seven criteria with a short definition for each. Score the last five pitches your agency received and check whether the scores would have matched what happened. Agree the weights with your senior team, and set a diary date for the first quarterly review. Once the pitch decision is clear, the next question is how an opportunity moves from first call to a retained client, which is covered in the agency sales process from first call to retainer.
Decide which pitches your agency should chase.
If your agency spends too long on pitches that never close, get in touch. We will look at a sample of recent pitches with you and suggest where a scoring model would help most.
Talk about your agencyQuestions and answers
How do you score an agency pitch?
List the criteria that matter for winning work, such as the buyer's stated goal, budget, decision-makers, timing, fit, competition and evidence. Score each one from 0 to 5, weight the scores so they total 100, and add them up. Record one reason for each score, so that the result can be reviewed against the outcome later.
What makes an agency pitch worth pursuing?
A pitch is usually worth pursuing when the buyer has a clear commercial goal, a confirmed budget and a named decision-maker you can reach, and when the work fits your sectors and skills. Timing and the strength of your evidence also count. A pitch that scores low on the commercial goal should rarely go ahead, however good the other scores look.
Should an agency pitch for every invitation?
No. Pitching for every invitation spreads senior time across opportunities that are unlikely to close, and it can weaken the service given to current clients. Use one consistent test to decide. Pursue the pitches that score well, qualify the ones with gaps, and decline the rest politely, recording a clear reason for each decision so you can review it later.
How often should an agency review its pitch criteria?
Review the criteria and weights each quarter. Compare your scores with the results: wins, losses, hours spent and margin. Change one weight or threshold at a time, keep a note of each change, and avoid large shifts based on a small number of pitches. Several quarters of records give a fairer picture than a single result.